Senators should be elected in the view of the prime minister. After failing to get movement on the issue, he announced he will not fill 22 vacancies.

Senators should be elected in the view of the prime minister. After failing to get movement on the issue, he announced he will not fill 22 vacancies.
Photo Credit: Sean Kilpatrick/Canadian Press

Leader’s refusal to appoint senators ‘unusual’


Prime Minister Stephen Harper’s refusal to fill 22 vacancies in Canada’s Senate is “rather unusual” and probably illegal in the view of Gary Levy, who teaches political science at Carleton University and is an expert in Canadian Parliamentary Institutions.


Prime minister said to be posturing

Several senators have recently been embroiled in spending scandals and the refusal “gets him off the hook,” says Levy, in that it distances him from them in the lead-up to a federal election in October. Levy suggests Harper is posturing and, that if elected, he would eventually fill the vacancies.

Canada’s Parliament has two houses with equal powers and legislation must be passed by both, as well as by the queen’s representative, the governor-general. The House of Commons is elected and the Senate is appointed by the prime minister.

A signed hand-out photo shows Prime Minister Stephen Harper with suspended former Conservative Senator Mike Duffy.  The photo is an exhibit in the trial of Duffy on 31 charges related to inappropriate Senate expenses.
A signed hand-out photo shows Prime Minister Stephen Harper with suspended former Conservative Senator Mike Duffy. The photo is an exhibit in the trial of Duffy on 31 charges related to inappropriate Senate expenses. © Justin Tang/hand out photo/Canadian Press

Provinces leery of Senate change

The Senate was originally created to give representation to Canada’s five regions—now ten provinces and three territories. It is often called the chamber of sober second thought. It may take more time to examine legislation, sometimes finding problems that the House missed, and it may initiate policy studies and benefit from the expertise of appointed senators.

There have been on-going calls to either change the appointment process for the Senate or to abolish it altogether. The Supreme Court recently ruled that any change would require constitutional amendment. That would require agreement from most of the provinces and some provinces have steadfastly resisted. This has frustrated the prime minister.

Prime minister tries ‘to force the issue’

“He would like to have an elected Senate and he’s tried over the last several years reform the Senate to make it into an elected body and he has been unsuccessful in doing that,” says Levy.

“So with a bit of frustration on his part because there’s no agreement on what changes would be made by a constitutional amendment…he’s tried to force the issue by saying he’s not going to appoint any more senators until the provinces and people generally agree on a new system of naming senators.”

A Vancouver lawyer has launched a suit in Federal Court to try to compel Harper to fill the 22 vacancies in the 105-seat Senate. Levy’s opinion is that the lawyer will win and that Harper will say he is obliged to make the appointments.

Prof. Gary Levy says this government has tended “to play fast and loose with our instituions.”
Prof. Gary Levy says this government has tended “to play fast and loose with our instituions.”

Opposition parties want change too

However, if Harper is thrown out of office in October it would fall to the party that wins to decide what to do.  The opposition New Democratic Party favours abolishing the senate by constitutional means and says it would seek agreement from the provinces. Levy says such an agreement would be unlikely.

Should the Liberal party gain power, it would like to change the appointment process by creating an independent body to advise the prime minister on the appointments. “That, they say, would solve the problem that we have now which is  unfortunate appointments—people keep getting in trouble and causing the institution to be in such disrepute.” says Levy. He notes something similar exists in the British Parliament, upon which Canada’s Parliament is based.

Government has ‘played fast and loose’ with our institutions

Levy takes a dim view of Harper’s declaration that he will no longer make Senate appointments. “I think it’s very important that we respect our institutions, that we make them work properly, the way they were intended, that we don’t play fast and loose with our institutions which I think the present government has tended to do with things like it’s fixed election date, and prorogation in the face of non-confidence, other things that were not intended to work the way they’ve been doing it.

“It causes all kinds of problems down the road. I think we need to get back to basics regarding how our institutions work and are supposed to work. And certainly not appointing senators is something that has never been tried before.”

Posted in Politics, Society

Do you want to report an error or a typo? Click here!

@*@ Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 characters available

Note: By submitting your comments, you acknowledge that Radio Canada International has the right to reproduce, broadcast and publicize those comments or any part thereof in any manner whatsoever. Radio Canada International does not endorse any of the views posted. Your comments will be pre-moderated and published if they meet netiquette guidelines.

Netiquette »

When you express your personal opinion in an online forum, you must be as courteous as if you were speaking with someone face-to-face. Insults and personal attacks will not be tolerated. To disagree with an opinion, an idea or an event is one thing, but to show disrespect for other people is quite another. Great minds don’t always think alike—and that’s precisely what makes online dialogue so interesting and valuable.

Netiquette is the set of rules of conduct governing how you should behave when communicating via the Internet. Before you post a message to a blog or forum, it’s important to read and understand these rules. Otherwise, you may be banned from posting.

  1.’s online forums are not anonymous. Users must register, and give their full name and place of residence, which are displayed alongside each of their comments. reserves the right not to publish comments if there is any doubt as to the identity of their author.
  2. Assuming the identity of another person with intent to mislead or cause harm is a serious infraction that may result in the offender being banned.
  3.’s online forums are open to everyone, without regard to age, ethnic origin, religion, gender or sexual orientation.
  4. Comments that are defamatory, hateful, racist, xenophobic, sexist, or that disparage an ethnic origin, religious affiliation or age group will not be published.
  5. In online speak, writing in ALL CAPS is considered yelling, and may be interpreted as aggressive behaviour, which is unpleasant for the people reading. Any message containing one or more words in all caps (except for initialisms and acronyms) will be rejected, as will any message containing one or more words in bold, italic or underlined characters.
  6. Use of vulgar, obscene or objectionable language is prohibited. Forums are public places and your comments could offend some users. People who use inappropriate language will be banned.
  7. Mutual respect is essential among users. Insulting, threatening or harassing another user is prohibited. You can express your disagreement with an idea without attacking anyone.
  8. Exchanging arguments and opposing views is a key component of healthy debate, but it should not turn into a dialogue or private discussion between two users who address each other without regard for the other participants. Messages of this type will not be posted.
  9. Radio Canada International publishes contents in five languages. The language used in the forums has to be the same as the contents we publish. The usage of other languages, with the exception of some words, is forbidden. Messages that are off-topic will not be published.
  10. Making repetitive posts disrupts the flow of discussions and will not be tolerated.
  11. Adding images or any other type of file to comments is forbidden. Including hyperlinks to other websites is allowed, as long as they comply with netiquette. Radio Canada International  is in no way responsible for the content of such sites, however.
  12. Copying and pasting text written by someone else, even if you credit the author, is unacceptable if that text makes up the majority of your comment.
  13. Posting any type of advertising or call to action, in any form, to Radio Canada International  forums is prohibited.
  14. All comments and other types of content are moderated before publication. Radio Canada International  reserves the right to refuse any comment for publication.
  15. Radio Canada International  reserves the right to close a forum at any time, without notice.
  16. Radio Canada International  reserves the right to amend this code of conduct (netiquette) at any time, without notice.
  17. By participating in its online forums, you allow Radio Canada International to publish your comments on the web for an indefinite time. This also implies that these messages will be indexed by Internet search engines.
  18. Radio Canada International has no obligation to remove your messages from the web if one day you request it. We invite you to carefully consider your comments and the consequences of their posting.