Yesterday was the first day for an order requiring mask wearing in all indoor spaces in Toronto, Canada’s largest city. Similar mandatory mask wearing bylaws have just been enacted in the national capital, Ottawa, throughout much of eastern Ontario and soon throughout cities around Toronto. At the end of the month the major urban centre of Montreal, Quebec will also enact a mandatory mask law for all indoor spaces.
As Toronto’s mandatory mask law came into effect yesterday, a small group gathered in Toronto to protest the order and to ride on the public transit subway where mask wearing against the potential spread of the coronavirus has been in place since July 2. Many of the group were wearing T-shirts saying ‘hugs over masks’ with some signs reading ‘no fear’.
The group gathered at a major downtown Toronto intersection first and then descended into the subway system for a short ride before re-emerging at another downtown intersection where they engaged with passersby about their opposition to mask wearing.
LIVE in Toronto
Protestors state their case for why they oppose mandatory masks. pic.twitter.com/Nbx3Rz593Z
— The Post Millennial (@TPostMillennial) July 7, 2020
Among the group was a woman who this week went to the city’s St Joseph’s hospital emergency room for a possible broken finger but was refused treatment because she wasn’t wearing a mask.
Speaking to CP24 Letitia Montana said, “Why do our rights have to be suppressed, so that somebody else would feel better? Is that the world we want to live in? That is what has led us to the greatest atrocities throughout history that have oppressed minorities, have oppressed dissonance. Anyone that doesn’t follow … you’re an outcast, you’ve gotta be killed, you’ve gotta be ostracized. IIs that the Canada we want to live in?
Another of the protesters Chris Saccoccia, quoted by the Toronto Sun said his opposition was over concerns of setting government control precedents, “I’m not opposed to you wearing a mask if you want to — what we’re opposed to is mandatory mask-wearing. We’re all about freedom of choice. Next month, it’s going to be no freedom of choice for contact tracing and then it’s going to be no freedom of choice for vaccination and then no freedom of choice for their biometric digital ID. This is the progression. This is why they tried to make masks mandatory at the end of a pandemic.”
Toronto Mayor John Tory who has strongly encouraged mask wearing said he was unconcerned by the protest noting it involved only about 40 people in a city of millions.
Failing to wear a mask in the subway or indoors has the potential for fines in the several hundreds of dollars but none of the group was charged.
A city councillor and member of the Toronto Transit Commission board (TTC) labelled the protest as a ‘political stunt’. Quoted by CBC Shelley Caroll said, “I hope that people who want to safely ride the TTC understand that we’re going to do our level best to make sure this little movement that started today is a short-lived one.”
Following the TTC mask requirement about 60 percent of subway riders were wearing masks. On Monday, the day before the new city bylaw on wearing masks, about 84 per cent of riders were wearing masks.
Ontario’s Ministry of Health reports only 112 new positive tests for the virus, which is the second lowest number of new cases since March. There were no COVID deaths on Monday, and two deaths reported on Tuesday.
- Toronto Sun: J.Yuen: Jul 7/20: Protester compares mandatory mask bylaw to history’s ‘greatest atrocities’
- CP24 (via CTV)” Jul 7/20: Protesters ride TTC without masks to call for an end to mandatory masks in Toronto
- Ottawa Citizen: R. Denley: Jul 7/20 OpEd – Numbers don’t support the need to mandate face masks in Ottawa
- CBC: A.Carter: Jul 7/20: TTC board member denounces anti-mask protest as ‘political stunt’
- CIty News: Jul 7/20: Small group protests against masks in downtown Toronto