Prime Minister Justin Trudeau told the Commons, “I expect better behaviour of myself."

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau told the Commons, “I expect better behaviour of myself."
Photo Credit: PC / Adrian Wyld/Canadian Press

House of Commons in an uproar

Canada’s Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has repeatedly apologized in the House of Commons for his physical encounter with opposition members of Parliament (MPs) during a heated session last evening. Physical encounters never happen in Canada’s Parliament. The rules are such that if an MP even calls another a liar they are ejected and must apologize before returning.

Opposition MPs were furious over government attempts to limit the time to debate a law on doctor-assisted suicide.
Opposition MPs were furious over government attempts to limit the time to debate a law on doctor-assisted suicide. © CBC

Time pressure infuriated MPs

Tensions were high yesterday as the ruling Liberals tried to limit debate on a highly controversial proposed law on doctor-assisted death. The Supreme Court of Canada gave the government a deadline of June 6 to pass the law. But opposition members argued it is better to create a good law than to meet the deadline. They demanded more time to give MPs a say on what is a highly emotional issue.

The fracas occurred when the opposition Conservative whip was blocked by members of the New Democratic Party on the floor of the Commons. He needed to pass before there could be a vote to give the cabinet control of the schedule.

Opposition MP Ruth Ellen Brosseau told the Commons the prime minister elbowed her in the chest. She left and so was unable to vote on the motion.
Opposition MP Ruth Ellen Brosseau told the Commons the prime minister elbowed her in the chest. She left and so was unable to vote on the motion. © CBC

Prime minister muscles through

The prime minister left his place, strode across the floor and through the knot of MPs. He seized the arm of the whip and guided him though the crowd. In doing so, he appeared to accidentally elbow opposition MP Ruth Ellen Brosseau who became upset, left the chamber and missed the vote. (see video)

The leader of her party Thomas Mulcair was furious and called Trudeau “pathetic.” Trudeau replied with the f-bomb.

Today, leader of the Conservative opposition, Rona Ambrose rose in the House to say that such behaviour is not tolerated in the workplace and should not be tolerated in the Commons. And she again demanded MPs be given more time to debate.

Conservative Leader Rona Ambrose succeeded in getting the ruling Liberals to withdraw their motion enabling them to limit debate.
Conservative Leader Rona Ambrose succeeded in getting the ruling Liberals to withdraw their motion enabling them to limit debate. © Adrian Wyld/Canadian Press

Score one for the opposition

This morning Trudeau apologized for his behaviour but would not address the time limit. By afternoon, the Liberals lifted the motion and promised to extend the sitting to give opposition members more time to examine the legislation. The opposition Conservatives who were booted out of office in October 2015 also succeeded in taking Trudeau down a notch or two. Upon taking office, Trudeau famously promised “sunny ways” and he has remained popular.

The Commons commotion dominated the news in Canada for much of the day. There are those who are highly critical of Trudeau’s behaviour, those who think he was justified and others who think the media are making too much of the issue.

Keep ’em two sword lengths apart

As an interesting aside, the Canadian House of Commons seating is arranged with two groups of seats facing across an aisle. This is in keeping with the ancient British custom of keeping the government and opposition two swords lengths apart. A good idea apparently.

Categories: Politics, Society
Tags: , , ,

Do you want to report an error or a typo? Click here!

For reasons beyond our control, and for an undetermined period of time, our comment section is now closed. However, our social networks remain open to your contributions.