This photo from Ukrainian investigators looking into the Flight PS752 crash shows part of the plane's cockpit. Initial thoughts are that at lease one missile blew up near the front of the plane sending shrapnel tearing through the cockpit and killing the crew immediately. (Ukrainian Presidential Press Service/Handout via Reuters)

PS752: How could Iran have made such a terrible tragic mistake?

After initially denying they were at fault, Iran quickly backtracked saying the shot down the passenger jet by mistake?

But with modern sophisticated systems how could a large, slow moving, and climbing jetliner be mistaken for a “hostile” fighter jet or cruise missile?

James McKay (PhD) is a professor of political science at the Royal Military College in Kingston Ontario.

Listen

There should have been several clear indications that PS752 was not hostile and was in fact a large passenger jet.

James McKay, political science professor at the Royal Military College of Canada. (supplied)

Strategists say a hostile craft would have been smaller, faster and travelling towards a potentially identifiable target on a probable level course with no identification. In this case, PS752 would have been on a Standard Instrument Departure (SID) had its identifying transponder on, ‘squawking’ an allocated IFF (Identification Friend or Foe) transponder code as a non-threat. As a radar passes over a plane the transponder is triggered to respond with a 4-digit code, while an additional selection on the radar unit can read altitude.

A TOR M1 Surface to air missile launcher, front radar folded down during movement. The missiles are launched out of the top of the vehicle (AP photo)

PS752 was relatively slow, and climbing away from the city -outbound- not inbound- on a known regular flight path..

So what went wrong?

So many possibilities.

Communications breakdown is likely along a system involving civilian aviation authorities, the regime leadership, the regular military, and the separate Revolutionary Guards military command which operates the missile system and going down through the lower levels of the Guards down to the missile battery and the crew of the particular launcher.

Iran had launched a missile attack on military bases in Iraq just hours before and McKay notes the Iranians were fearing American reprisal attacks. He says the crew of the launcher may have been shutting down their radar and communications periodically to prevent their location from being identified and becoming a target for anti-radiation missiles which seek and track radar emissions. This meant they may have missed critical information about passenger flights from the still operating airfield.

Radar track shows flights from Tehran airport showing PS 752 was on a standard flight path and climbing when  communication suddenly ended, two minutes after leaving the runway ( Flight24)

McKay also says the system “Identification friend or foe” (IFF) system may have had a malfunction but the direction of flight he says casts doubt on that.

He also says it may be a question of training of the Revolutionary Guards operating these deadly missiles. Also playing into the tragic equation may be an issue of crew fatigue affecting judgement, the force having been on high alert for up to several days.

While McKay says the case will be studied by military analysts in Iran and elsewhere in efforts to avoid such mistakes, and the civil aviation body may also rethink policy about operations in hostile or potentially hostile airspace, will this tragedy prevent anything like it in the future?

The TOR M1 is fitted with 9m330 missiles 2.4m tall. The missile contains about 15kg of explosive designed to spray metal shrapnel into the target aircraft. (Allocet-wiki commons)

There have already been previous cases .

On September 1, 1983, a Korean Airlines 747 accidentally strayed into Soviet airspace. Thinking it was a similar looking American spy-plane it was ordered shot down even though the jet interceptors closing in on it said it appeared not to be a spy-plane. Some 269 people died

In July 1988, an American warship shot down an Iranian Airbus flying between Iran and Dubai claiming it was thought to be an Iraqi F-14. Some 290 died, in a tragedy noted this week by Iranian President Rouhlani in a tweet.

In 2003 an American patriot missile downed a British military Tornado GR4 in Kuwait killing its two crew because the jet potentially had a problem with its IFF, or interference prevented a clear signal. This led to the Patriot crew thinking they were being targeted by an anti-radiation missile homing in on the radiation emitted by the American unit. Training and communication issues appear to be factors.

In July 2014, a Malaysian flight from Amsterdam to Kuala Lumpur was felled by a Russian missile over Ukraine apparently fired by Russian-backed Ukrainian separatists, and also apparently because they thought it was a Ukrainian cargo plane.

additional information

Categories: International, Politics
Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Do you want to report an error or a typo? Click here!

For reasons beyond our control, and for an undetermined period of time, our comment section is now closed. However, our social networks remain open to your contributions.