World Press Freedom Index: The darker the colour, the worse the situation.

World Press Freedom Index: The darker the colour, the worse the situation.
Photo Credit: RSF

Press freedom in Canada…not as good as you think

The group Reporters Without Borders has released its annual estimates of press freedom in countries around the world

It’s called the “World Press Freedom Index”.

One might expect Canada to be near top of the list in terms of freedom of its press.

Not so.

In fact in this year’s analysis, Canada is not in the top ten, it’s not even in the top 20!

Montreal journalist Patrice Lagace at La Presse was the first to discover Quebec provincial police had easily obtained a warrant to monitor his mobile phone calls in hopes of tracking the source of police internal leaks. © Radio-Canada

Canada has slipped down to 22 on the list of 180 countries, dropping four spots from the previous year, and a 10 place drop in the year before that.

The reasons for the decline this year are due to several incidents including police spying on at least 6 journalists mobile phones in the mostly French speaking province of Quebec.  The pretext was to try to discover leaks in the police department.

After Lagace, Isabelle Richer and Marie-Maude Denis, hosts of Radio-Canada’s investigative program Enquête, both say their phones were tracked by Quebec provincial police. The police monitoring of journalists phones was one of the reasons Canada’s ranking fell in press freedom
After Lagace, Isabelle Richer and Marie-Maude Denis, hosts of Radio-Canada’s investigative program Enquête, both say their phones were tracked by Quebec provincial police. The police monitoring of journalists phones was one of the reasons Canada’s ranking fell in press freedom © Radio-Canada

Another case involves a demand by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) for a reporter to hand over background materials and sources in relation to a terrorism investigation. Police also seized a reporter’s computer during a raid on a newspaper.

Another independent reporter is facing a lengthy jail sentence for his arrest last year while covering a protest at a huge hydro-electric project in Labrador.

The report says “Journalists are “democracy’s watchdogs” and the protection of their sources is the “cornerstone of freedom of the press.” Although enshrined in such terms by the European Court of Human Rights, these principles are being attacked in an increasingly open manner all over the world, including in the democratic countries that first proclaimed them”

The analysis also notes increasing attacks on the media and scapegoating such as the increasing use of terms like “fake news”.

It points out several new surveillance laws in democracies such as in Germany (ranked 16th in the 2017 Index),  where a new law in October 2016 extended the mass surveillance powers of the Federal  Intelligence Agency (BND) without making any exception for journalists.

In Britain surveillance powers of intelligence agencies were greatly increased under the Investigatory Powers Act (aka Snoopers Charter) again with no protection for journalists.

In Canada a similar law, C-51-Anti-Terrorism law, has also expanded police powers.

Rallies were held across Canada in 2015 to protest against the Conservative government’s Anti-Terrorism Law.
Rallies were held across Canada in 2015 to protest against the Conservative government’s Anti-Terrorism Law which gives police new surveillance and other powers with no protection for journalists and their sources. It was passed later that year © Justin Tang/Canadian Press

While a democracy like Canada has fallen to 22nd place, the U.S is now listed in 43rd spot.

In an statement, Delphine Halgand, RSF’s North America director, said the decline in press freedom in the two countries has been alarming.

“Both of these countries pride themselves on their strong democratic values, which should include the freedom for journalists to report on issues of public concern without fear of reprisals,”  she said.

“But what we are seeing is that journalists’ sources are increasingly under threat, reporters are now facing jail time for covering protests, and verbal attacks meant to undermine the work of journalists are coming from some of the highest positions in government”.

Norway was highest on the list.

In other rankings, Jamaica was 8th,  Australia 19th, the UK 40th, Hungary came in 71st, Greece 88th,  Brazil 103rd, and at the very bottom was N. Korea.

The World Press Freedom Index was begun in 2002 and is an indication of the indication of the independence of media, safety of journalists, pluralism and quality of legislative framework in each country.

Additional information- sources

Categories: Economy, International, Society
Tags: , , ,

Do you want to report an error or a typo? Click here!

For reasons beyond our control, and for an undetermined period of time, our comment section is now closed. However, our social networks remain open to your contributions.