The provinces have long strictly controlled sale of alcohol, and certain other things, within each province. An SCC ruling today could change that. Photo: Chris Young-CP

Free-the-beer: Supreme court ruling today

Landmark ruling on provincial trade regulations

While the Canadian federal government negotiates international free trade deals, it’s not the same within Canada.

The Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) has ruled today on a case known colloquially as “free the beer”.

The legal battles began in 2012 when a retired New Brunswick man, Gerald Comeau, drove from his home in New Brunswick into Quebec to buy alcohol where it is less expensive. As he had done two or three times a year, he bought several cases of beer and some bottles of liquor. Upon crossing back into New Brunswick, police charged him with not buying alcohol through the New Brunswick provincial liquor board.

Under a New Brunswick law, you are allowed to possess a limit of 12 pints of beer not purchased in the province.

It’s a “no go” for Mr Comeau

The top court ruling which could have had widespread repercussions on inter-provincial trade has upheld the New Brunswick appeal and as such provincial jurisdiction in such matters.

The Canadian provinces have strict rules concerning such things as alcohol and tobacco that you can buy in one province and take across the provincial boundary into another.

The Beer Store- Gananoque, Ontario, Each Province has a near monopoly on alcohol sales and taxes, and also controls and collects taxes on tobacco, and regulates sales of a variety of products and services within the province. Photo: Google streetview

In 2016, Comeau initially won his argument in New Brunswick court that the provincial law contravenes Section 121 of the Constitution Act, which reads “All articles of the growth, produce, or manufacture of any one of the provinces shall, from and after the union, be admitted free into each of the other provinces”.

Gerard Comeau buying beer in Quebec after his 2016 court win in New Brunswick court. The province has appealed to the Supreme Court of Canada which will hand down its decision today Photo: Serge Bouchard- Radio-Canada

The provincial Attorney-General then appealed the case to the Supreme Court of Canada which agreed it would hear the case.

At stake for all provinces are vast sums of revenue in taxes from alcohol and tobacco sales within their jurisdiction that could potentially be lost if people can cross the boundary into other provinces where taxes are lower.

In N.B, alcohol can be taxed in some cases as high as 89.8 per cent.

The case could have had implications not only for alcohol sales, but also tobacco, and when it becomes legal, cannabis sales. It could also have affect a number of other provincial laws and trade rulings such as selling chickens, eggs, and milk, and even how some professionals work across provincial borders.

In its decision today the SCC noted the potential effects of opening up so-called free trade within Canada, “If to be ‘admitted free’ is understood as a constitutional guarantee of free trade, the potential reach of s. 121 is vast. Agricultural supply management schemes, public health-driven prohibitions, environmental controls, and innumerable comparable regulatory measures that incidentally impede the passage of goods crossing provincial borders may be invalid.”

In its decision against Mr Comeau, the Supreme Court clarified the scope of s-121 of the Constitution. “Section 121 does not impose absolute free trade across Canada,” the top court held. “We further conclude that s.121 prohibits governments from levying tariffs or tariff-like measures (measures that in essence and purpose burden the passage of goods across a provincial border); but, s. 121 does not prohibit governments from adopting laws and regulatory schemes directed to other goals that have incidental effects on the passage of goods across provincial borders”.

Additional information –sources

Categories: Economy, Politics, Society
Tags: , , , , ,

Do you want to report an error or a typo? Click here!

@*@ Comments

Leave a Reply

Note: By submitting your comments, you acknowledge that Radio Canada International has the right to reproduce, broadcast and publicize those comments or any part thereof in any manner whatsoever. Radio Canada International does not endorse any of the views posted. Your comments will be pre-moderated and published if they meet Netiquette guidelines.

When you express your personal opinion in an online forum, you must be as courteous as if you were speaking with someone face-to-face. Insults and personal attacks will not be tolerated. To disagree with an opinion, an idea or an event is one thing, but to show disrespect for other people is quite another. Great minds don’t always think alike—and that’s precisely what makes online dialogue so interesting and valuable.

Netiquette is the set of rules of conduct governing how you should behave when communicating via the Internet. Before you post a message to a blog or forum, it’s important to read and understand these rules. Otherwise, you may be banned from posting.

  1.’s online forums are not anonymous. Users must register, and give their full name and place of residence, which are displayed alongside each of their comments. reserves the right not to publish comments if there is any doubt as to the identity of their author.
  2. Assuming the identity of another person with intent to mislead or cause harm is a serious infraction that may result in the offender being banned.
  3.’s online forums are open to everyone, without regard to age, ethnic origin, religion, gender or sexual orientation.
  4. Comments that are defamatory, hateful, racist, xenophobic, sexist, or that disparage an ethnic origin, religious affiliation or age group will not be published.
  5. In online speak, writing in ALL CAPS is considered yelling, and may be interpreted as aggressive behaviour, which is unpleasant for the people reading. Any message containing one or more words in all caps (except for initialisms and acronyms) will be rejected, as will any message containing one or more words in bold, italic or underlined characters.
  6. Use of vulgar, obscene or objectionable language is prohibited. Forums are public places and your comments could offend some users. People who use inappropriate language will be banned.
  7. Mutual respect is essential among users. Insulting, threatening or harassing another user is prohibited. You can express your disagreement with an idea without attacking anyone.
  8. Exchanging arguments and opposing views is a key component of healthy debate, but it should not turn into a dialogue or private discussion between two users who address each other without regard for the other participants. Messages of this type will not be posted.
  9. Radio Canada International publishes contents in five languages. The language used in the forums has to be the same as the contents we publish or in one of the two official languages, English or French. The usage of other languages, with the exception of some words, is forbidden. Messages that are off-topic will not be published.
  10. Making repetitive posts disrupts the flow of discussions and will not be tolerated.
  11. Adding images or any other type of file to comments is forbidden. Including hyperlinks to other websites is allowed, as long as they comply with netiquette. Radio Canada International  is in no way responsible for the content of such sites, however.
  12. Copying and pasting text written by someone else, even if you credit the author, is unacceptable if that text makes up the majority of your comment.
  13. Posting any type of advertising or call to action, in any form, to Radio Canada International  forums is prohibited.
  14. All comments and other types of content are moderated before publication. Radio Canada International  reserves the right to refuse any comment for publication.
  15. Radio Canada International  reserves the right to close a forum at any time, without notice.
  16. Radio Canada International  reserves the right to amend this code of conduct (netiquette) at any time, without notice.
  17. By participating in its online forums, you allow Radio Canada International to publish your comments on the web for an indefinite time. This also implies that these messages will be indexed by Internet search engines.
  18. Radio Canada International has no obligation to remove your messages from the web if one day you request it. We invite you to carefully consider your comments and the consequences of their posting.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


One comment on “Free-the-beer: Supreme court ruling today
  1. Avatar Peter Ashcroft says:

    Whereas Brunei is a dry Muslim country, non Bruneians are restricted in the amount of alcohol they can bring in, and then only for their own consumption.