(public comments may take 24hrs before appearing)
One of the main gun-control lobby groups in Canada has sent a letter to the newly re-elected Liberal government urging strong and immediate anti-firearms actions.
The group PolySeSouvient was formed after the deliberate killings of 14 female students at Montreal’s Ecole Polytechnique University, 30 years ago.
The letter sent by the group on Monday to Bill Blair, the new federal public safety minister and to media outlets, calls for an immediate moratorium on sales of so-called ‘assault-style’ firearms and suggests the government should follow the New Zealand policy of banning virtually all semi-auto rifles. The group also calls for a permanent ban on importation and manufacture of handguns in Canada.
The Liberal government had said it would take action against semi-automatic gun ownership, specifically mentioning consumer versions of in the ARmalite-15 style and variants. This would be done through a mandatory buy-back programme of the so-called military-style rifles, and would enable municipalities to ban handguns.
Bill Blair had said earlier that a buy back programme for the rifles would cost taxpayers between $400-$600 million. The Poly letter calls on the government to act on gun control measures it proposed such as allowing cities to ban handguns but goes further by requesting a national ban on handgun ownership.
Tony Bernardo is president of the firearm-owners advocacy group, Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
During the recent federal election campaign he said “Trudeau’s hyperbolic rhetoric is purely designed to whip up public sentiment against our community (…) despite the statistical evidence that firearms owners are the most law-abiding people in our country”.
The Poly letter also states “According to Statistics Canada, the number of firearm homicides has increased for the fourth year in a row, with the number of firearm homicides more than doubling (from 131 in 2013 to 266 in 2017) and the current rate representing the “highest rate observed in Canada since 1992”
However the statistic for 2018 was released on Wednesday, noting that, “the national rates for both firearm-related (-8%) and gang-related (-5%) homicides decreased in 2018. This marks the first decrease in firearm-related homicides since 2013”
The Canadian Sporting Arms and Ammunition Association represents the industry in Canada including 4,500 small, mostly-family run businesses. At a September news conference in Ottawa, the managing director said that while they are not experts on mental health, nor experts on gangs or crime, they are firearms experts and should be part of government discussions.
The CSAAA was among a group which commissioned an economic impact study from the Conference Board of Canada. That 2019 report noted that hunting and sport shooting pumped $8.5 Billion into the Canadian economy in 2018 and supported over 48,000 full time equivalent jobs.
Quoted in the Edmonton Journal, Len Kucey owner of a gun shop and indoor range said a handgun ban would devastate the business. “It would be total devastation all around, for the landlord, employees, owners, our members”
In response to the latest call by PolySeSouvient, Bernardo said,” It’s a shame that a handful of anti-gun activists drown out the voices of 2.2 million lawful, licensed Canadians – Canadians who respect the laws of our land and practice their sport safely and with respect to others”, adding, “Canada is a very safe country, not in spite of the culture of safety Canadian firearms owners represent, but because of it. The truthless accusations of the anti-gun lobby fly in the face of the honest men and women that practice the time-honoured traditions of Canada’s oldest sport.”
Bernardo says the problem of gun crime lies not with legal owners, but with societal issues including misguided policies. In a newsletter the CSSA notes “Canadian police agencies do not track violent criminals.
Nor do they check up on the 300,000 people who are prohibited from possessing firearms by court order. Instead, our government tracks and runs daily background checks on federally-licensed, RCMP-vetted firearm owners – those Canadians least likely to commit a crime.”
As reported by the CBC, the government alleges many handguns and other firearms used in gun violence are stolen from law-abiding individuals or businesses, or purchased legally and then diverted to the illicit market.
However, statistics to prove or disprove the claim seem hard to get. In response to a question by Member of Parliament Brad Trost’s Order Paper Question Q-2479 – June 19, 2019 to then Public Safety Minister Ralph Goodale, the response from the Canadian Firearms Programme noted there is “no national registry to track illegal or stolen handguns found at crime scenes”, and that “the CFP does not collect or track statistics with regard to the origin of illegal or stolen handguns.”
Retired RCMP officer Dennis Young, in an access-to-information request, found however that some 813 firearms of various types were lost or stolen from police and public agencies between 2005-2019.
In asking for an immediate moratorium on what they term as “assault rifles” the gun-control lobby group asks of the Liberal government, “An immediate moratorium on new sales of assault weapons would be entirely consistent with your party’s election promise. Why allow the continued sale of weapons which are to be banned and bought-back in the near future?”
A spokesman for Blair, Scott Bardsley said the minister appreciates the group’s support of the government’s promise to ban military-style assault rifles, adding the minister looks forward to reviewing the letter.
There are approximately 2.2 million licenced firearms owners in Canada.
- RCI: L Sevunts: Feb 15/19: 30 years after Polytechnique massacre, Canada’s gun debate rages on
- RCI: L Desjardins: Feb 11/19:: Stronger gun control urged by doctors
- RCI: M Montgomery: May 1/19: Doctors and guns- a different view
- Conference Board of Canada The Economic Footprint of Angling, Hunting, Trapping and Sport Shooting in Canada
- Canadian Press (via CBC) J. Bronskill: Nov 26/19: End assault style gun sales now, Polytechnique group tells Liberals
- CBC: K. Harris: Sep 20/19: Liberals promise to prohibit semi-automatic assault rifles, allow cities to ban handguns
- Edmonton Journal: J Herring: Aug 24/19: Sporting gun advocacy group says recreational weapons are economic drivers
- CSAAA- news conference- Youtube Sep 2019
- StatsCan Police reported crime statistics, 2018
- StatsCan Homicide rate Canada-2018