One day after the province of Alberta said it would suspend administering the first dose of the Oxford AstraZeneca vaccine, the province of Ontario said it was also suspending giving AstraZeneca and Covishield as a first dose as a defence against COVID-19.
Covishield is the AstraZeneca vaccine made under licence in India.
Alberta cited lack of supply as the primary reason, while also mentioning concerns of serious side effects of blood clotting, Ontario however cited rising concern about the side effects as the primary reason for pausing administering the vaccine over concerns of a very rare but serious side effect of blood clotting…
The two Canadian provinces join the countries of Norway, Denmark and Iceland which have stopped administering the AstraZeneca vaccine.
Ontario is Canada’s largest province and the one with the highest number of COVID positive cases and the second highest death toll at 8,342 after Quebec with over 11,000 deaths.
The Chief Medical Officer for Ontario, Dr. David Williams, said on Tuesday the decision to stop administering the AstraZeneca as a first dose was due to an increase officials had noticed in the rare blood clotting side effect. Although rare, the effects have been occurring anywhere from four to 28 days after vaccination.
As of last Sunday, just over 651,000 doses of the AstraZeneca vaccine were administered, while over 202,800 doses of the COVISHIELD vaccine were administered in Ontario. There have been at least12 known cases of blood clotting in Canada, with eight of them in Ontario. There have been three deaths from clotting with what is known as Vaccine-Induced Immune Thrombotic Thrombocytopenia (VITT). All victims were women over age 50 with one in Quebec, one in New Brunswick and one in Alberta.
Medical officials in Ontario said the “safety signals” of issues with the vaccine had increased from the typical 1 in 100,000, to roughly 1 in 60,000 doses. Therefore health officials at the Tuesday news conference said the decision to pause first dose use of AstraZeneca-Covishield was taken “out of an abundance of caution”.
Medical experts say the type of clotting that has been seen in these rare cases is different from typical blood clotting problems and is more difficult to treat.
As in Alberta, part of the reason for the Ontario decision is also due to increased availability of the PfizerBioNtech and Moderna vaccines which are based on a new mRNA technology. There have been no reported cases of the serious VITT side effect with these vaccines.
Ontario still has about 50,000 doses remaining of the AstraZeneca vaccine.
Dr Williams said information from Britain, which has largely vaccinated its population with the AstraZeneca shows a much reduced risk of the clotting side effect with the second dose. The side effect has been noticed as a one in 100,000 with the first dose, but the British data shows the chance of VITT is down to one in a million with the second dose.
The remaining stock will be used to give second doses.
A clinical trial is being conducted in Britain to determine the effects of using a different vaccine as a second dose.
Virtually all medical personnel insist that those who have already received the AstraZeneca vaccine made the right choice to get vaccinated as soon as possible. Now that the other vaccines are more available officials are saying the mRNA vaccines are preferable.
As to the continued use of AstraZeneca Andrew Morris, an infectious diseases doctor at Sinai Health and University Health Network in Toronto. says its still a very important tool in high infection areas.
Quoted by Post Media he said, “If we could get a billion doses of AstraZeneca to India, I would do it in a heartbeat, because so many people are dying. And yes, some of those people will die (from vaccine-induced blood clotting) but you’re going to be saving millions and millions of lives,”
- CBC: M Draaisma: May 11/21: Ontario will no longer give AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccine as first dose due to blood clot risk
- PostMedia: S Kirkey: May 11/21:’Very little excuse’ to continue to use AstraZeneca in Canada: infectious diseases specialist
- CP24: C Fox: May 11/21: Ontario to stop administering first doses of AstraZeneca vaccine ‘out of an abundance of caution’